Hearing that your roof insurance claim was denied can feel like a punch to the gut—especially after a major storm. You did everything right: called your insurance company, waited for the adjuster, and hoped for approval. Then the letter arrives: “Claim denied.”
If this sounds familiar, take a deep breath. You’re not out of options.
At Bella Construction, we’ve helped thousands of Western Pennsylvania homeowners through the storm restoration process, including those who faced an initial denial. In many cases, a denied claim can be appealed or re-evaluated—and with the right documentation and professional inspection, your outcome could change.
Here’s your guide to what to do next if your roof claim was denied—and how we can help you get the fair coverage you deserve.
Step 1: Don’t Panic (and Don’t Assume It’s Final)
First things first: a denied claim isn’t necessarily the end of the road.
Insurance companies often deny roof claims for reasons that can be challenged—especially if the damage wasn’t properly assessed. Adjusters are human, and sometimes they miss signs of storm damage or misunderstand what caused the issue.
Common reasons for denial include:
-
The adjuster said the damage was due to “wear and tear” instead of storm impact.
-
The roof was “too old” to qualify under your policy.
-
The report stated “no storm-related damage was found.”
-
The damage was labeled “cosmetic” and not functional.
The good news? Many of these denials can be appealed with the right evidence—and that starts with getting a second professional opinion.
Step 2: Get a Detailed Roof Inspection from a Professional
Before you accept the denial, schedule a free roof inspection with a licensed roofing contractor—preferably one with insurance restoration experience, like Bella Construction.
We’ll perform a comprehensive inspection, looking for damage that might have been overlooked by the insurance adjuster, such as:
-
Hail or wind damage to shingles, flashing, or vents
-
Hidden leaks or water infiltration
-
Broken seals or lifted shingles from high winds
-
Structural damage from fallen branches or debris
Our trained eye can often identify clear indicators of storm impact that an insurance adjuster might have missed in a quick walkaround.
Afterward, we’ll provide a detailed inspection report with photos and documentation—crucial evidence if you plan to appeal the denial.
Step 3: Review the Insurance Denial Letter
Next, carefully read your denial letter from the insurance company. This document outlines exactly why your claim was denied and which sections of your policy they used to justify that decision.
Look for details like:
-
The stated cause of damage (“age,” “wear and tear,” “improper installation”)
-
Specific policy exclusions cited
-
Any mention of missed deadlines or incomplete documentation
If the language seems confusing—don’t worry. Insurance jargon is hard to navigate, and that’s where Bella Construction can help explain what’s really going on. We can translate the denial letter into plain English and tell you what your next move should be.
Step 4: File an Appeal (The Right Way)
If your professional inspection reveals legitimate storm damage, you have the right to appeal the insurance company’s decision.
Here’s how to do it effectively:
-
Gather all documentation.
Include your denial letter, your policy’s declarations page, the original adjuster’s report, and Bella’s inspection report with photos. -
Write a concise appeal letter.
Clearly state why you believe the denial was incorrect. Point to the professional findings that contradict the insurer’s assessment. -
Request a reinspection.
Ask the insurance company to send a new adjuster—or request that your roofing contractor be present during the reinspection to ensure nothing is missed. -
Stay professional and persistent.
Avoid emotional language. Focus on facts, dates, and documentation. Appeals often take time, but many homeowners win their case with solid evidence.
At Bella Construction, we routinely work alongside homeowners and their insurance companies during this process. Our team can help you compile your documents, explain our findings, and even meet with adjusters to ensure all legitimate storm damage is properly recognized.
Step 5: Understand the Role of Depreciation and Coverage Type
Sometimes a “denial” is really a misunderstanding about coverage type.
For example, if your policy covers Actual Cash Value (ACV) instead of Replacement Cost Value (RCV), the insurance company may only pay for your roof’s depreciated value—not a full replacement.
In these cases, you might still receive partial payment, or you could qualify for additional funds once the repair is completed and verified.
Not sure which type of policy you have? Bella Construction can help you decode your insurance terms so you know exactly what’s covered and what isn’t. (We even have a full blog post explaining ACV vs. RCV if you want to dive deeper!)
Step 6: Consider an Independent Adjuster
If your appeal doesn’t move forward or you feel the process isn’t fair, you can hire a public adjuster or independent appraiser.
These professionals work for you, not the insurance company. They can reassess the damage, review your policy, and negotiate on your behalf.
While they charge a small percentage of the settlement, the results can often offset that cost—especially for large roofing projects.
Step 7: Explore Other Options
If you’ve exhausted your appeals and still can’t get approval, you may have other routes:
-
Partial repair: Sometimes your insurer will cover part of the damage (like specific slopes). Bella can help you repair what’s covered while preparing for full replacement later.
-
Out-of-pocket replacement: Bella offers financing options to help homeowners replace their roof without waiting for claim approval.
-
Community aid or grants: Some local or state programs occasionally assist with home restoration after major storms.
Either way, we’ll work with you to find the most affordable and effective solution to protect your home.
Why a Professional Roofing Partner Makes the Difference
Insurance companies respect facts and documentation—and that’s exactly what Bella Construction brings to the table.
With more than 30 years of experience and over 13,000 projects completed across Western Pennsylvania, we’ve seen every kind of claim scenario imaginable. Our job is to make sure homeowners like you aren’t left paying for storm damage that should have been covered.
When you work with Bella, you can expect:
-
Thorough inspections using industry-standard damage assessment methods
-
Clear photo evidence to support your claim
-
Communication with your insurance adjuster to clarify findings
-
Quality replacement materials from top manufacturers
-
Proper installation that meets warranty and code standards
-
A 2-Year Labor Warranty and priority service beyond that period
We’re not just here to replace your roof—we’re here to advocate for you.
Final Thoughts
A denied roof claim isn’t the end of your story—it’s just a challenge that needs the right team and the right information.
Insurance companies count on homeowners not knowing the process. But when you understand your rights and have a trusted roofing contractor like Bella Construction on your side, you can turn a “no” into a “yes.”
If your claim was denied, don’t give up. Let our experts take a look before you close the file.
Call 724-515-5163 or visit www.mybellaroof.com to schedule your free inspection today.
We’ll assess the damage, explain your options, and help you move forward with confidence—because at Bella Construction, we treat your home like it’s our own.